Amazon Echo Dot 5th Gen: Is It Worth the Upgrade? A Detailed Comparison and Review

Amazon recently released the Amazon Echo Dot 5th generation, and while it might look similar to its predecessor, there are some noteworthy upgrades and changes. However, with older Echo devices often going on sale during events like Prime Day or Black Friday, you might wonder if the 5th gen is worth the extra cost. Let’s dive into what’s new and see if this latest Echo Dot is worth your money.

1. Familiar Design with an Enhanced Display

At first glance, the Echo Dot 5th gen looks nearly identical to the 4th gen. However, there are subtle differences. The most noticeable change is the removal of the 3.5mm audio jack—a move that echoes Apple’s decision to eliminate headphone jacks. But the real upgrade is in the LED dot display. While the previous version only showed the time, the new display can now showcase additional information such as weather updates, song titles, and even spell-out words. This makes it more versatile and informative, although some users might prefer the simplicity of the older display, which was easier to read from a distance.

2. New Features for Added Convenience

Amazon has packed in some interesting new features in the Echo Dot 5th gen. One standout is the accelerometer, which lets you tap the side of the device to control music, snooze alarms, or stop a timer. While this feature works well, it might be a bit too sensitive, causing accidental pauses or skips in music. Thankfully, you can disable this feature if it becomes annoying. Another useful addition is the built-in temperature sensor, which allows you to trigger routines, like getting a notification if a room gets too hot or cold. Plus, for those who use Amazon’s Eero mesh Wi-Fi system, the Echo Dot 5th gen can now extend your Wi-Fi coverage by up to 1,000 feet—a smart move by Amazon to add more functionality to their smart speakers.

3. Sound Quality: Is It Really Better?

Amazon claims that the Echo Dot 5th gen has twice the bass of its predecessor and lower distortion. While the bass is indeed slightly better, the improvement isn’t as dramatic as the numbers suggest. If you’re expecting a significant jump in audio quality, you might be disappointed. The sound is crisper and clearer, especially at higher volumes, but it’s still not in the same league as Apple’s HomePod Mini, which, although more expensive, delivers far superior audio. If sound quality is your main priority, you might want to consider the larger Echo 4th gen, which offers much deeper bass and a fuller sound for just a bit more money during sales.

4. How Does It Compare to Older Versions?

The Echo Dot 5th gen shows noticeable improvements over the 3rd gen, particularly in clarity and distortion reduction. If you’re using an older model, upgrading to the 5th gen would offer a significant improvement in audio quality and functionality. However, if you already own the 4th gen and don’t use the Eero Wi-Fi system, the upgrades might not be compelling enough to warrant the switch. The two models are quite similar, and unless you’re interested in the new display or the Wi-Fi extension feature, sticking with the 4th gen could save you some money.

5. Should You Buy It?

Deciding whether to purchase the Echo Dot 5th gen depends largely on your needs. If you’re looking to add or replace a smart speaker in a room where you frequently listen to music, the larger Echo 4th gen might be a better choice due to its superior sound quality. However, if you’re looking for a smart speaker for your nightstand, the Echo Dot 5th gen with its new display and tap controls could be ideal. The clock display dims automatically at night, and the ability to stop alarms with a simple tap is a nice touch.

For Eero users, the Wi-Fi extension feature could be a game-changer, making the Echo Dot 5th gen a no-brainer. But if you already have the 4th gen and don’t need these new features, upgrading might not be necessary. However, if you’re still using the 3rd gen or an older model, the Echo Dot 5th gen offers enough new features and improvements to make it a worthy upgrade.

In conclusion, while the Echo Dot 5th gen brings some nice upgrades, whether it’s worth buying depends on your specific needs and what Echo device you currently own.

Leave a Comment